Oma the enemy alien

On June 2, 2023, I received an email from the National Archives that my grandmother’s alien file was available for download. Oma, as I called her, had emigrated from her native Germany to the United States, arriving in New York City by ship on May 22, 1927. She was processed through Ellis Island, married my grandfather (aka Opa) in 1929, and gave birth to her only child, my father, in 1936.
Among her various immigration documents, one in particular caught my attention: Form AR-AE-22. By the time the United States entered World War II on December 8, 1941, Opa had already naturalized, but Oma was still only a US permanent resident (aka green card holder). As such, she was subject to a Presidential proclamation requiring that Germans, Italians and Japanese register as enemy aliens.

While there were hints when I was growing up that World War II was a difficult period for my grandparents, they were always deeply patriotic and, with typical stoicism, never complained about their experience. Which only made me angrier to know that Oma—a young mother, housewife, and Red Cross volunteer—had been branded, without evidence, as an enemy.


I tried to imagine the anxiety my grandparents must have felt at the time, knowing that the US government could separate Oma from Opa and my dad and intern her or, worse, deport her to Hitler’s Germany. The image in my mind (which I eventually painted on canvas) was her being exposed and vulnerable to an approaching storm, caught in a whirlwind of government documents that threatened to cut her deeply.
And yet the passport photo stapled to Oma’s enemy alien application betrays no such fear. On the contrary, her style and smile are almost glamorous. Was she putting on a brave face? Or being subtly defiant? I’ll never know.
I do wonder, though, if the trauma my grandparents experienced was somehow passed down to me. In the painting, I represent this possibility by having my body stand in for Oma’s. That would certainly explain my fierce protectiveness of immigrants and my fury at the current administration's invocation of the Enemy Aliens Act to crush immigrants’ freedom of speech (particularly on behalf of Palestinians) and deport other immigrants (particularly Venezuelans) without due process.